The Toronto Maple Leafs aim to close out their bitter provincial rivals when they host the Ottawa Senators in Game 5 of their Eastern Conference first-round playoff series at Scotiabank Arena on Tuesday night.
With a commanding 3-1 series lead, Toronto looks to overcome their historical playoff elimination game struggles (1-12 in their last 13) while the Senators, fresh off a dramatic 4-3 overtime victory, hope to extend their season once more.
The Maple Leafs' balanced attack and home-ice advantage give them a 60% win probability according to advanced models, but Ottawa's desperate situation makes this classic Canadian rivalry showdown anything but predictable.
Toronto Maple Leafs vs. Ottawa Senators prediction: who will win?
For tonight's Toronto Maple Leafs vs Ottawa Senators matchup, our predictive model gives the Leafs a 70% chance of defeating the Sens.
Pre-game probabilities
Toronto Maple Leafs
Moneyline
Win %
70%
30%
Ottawa Senators
Toronto Maple Leafs: 70% win probability
- Superior offensive production (268 goals scored this season, ranking them among the league's top scoring teams)
- Exceptional recent form (WWWWW, showing they're peaking at the right time)
- Higher position in standings (2nd in Eastern Conference with 108 points compared to Ottawa's 6th place)
Ottawa Senators: 30% win probability
- Inconsistent recent performances (WLWWL, showing vulnerability in maintaining momentum)
- Defensive concerns (234 goals against, considerably more than Toronto's defensive record)
- Road disadvantage (facing the 2nd place team in the conference with a strong home record)
At Sporting Post, our unique prediction model combines insights from top NHL experts. Instead of sifting through hundreds of expert analyses across the web, you can rely on our predictions to understand the market's overall sentiment. We scan trusted sources, analyzing predictions, data, and opinions, and our AI assigns a confidence level to each prediction. We then average these levels to produce an 'expert opinion' win probability—reflecting the collective intelligence of the industry's leading NHL experts..
| Toronto Maple Leafs | Ottawa Senators | |
|---|---|---|
| Moneyline |
Best NHL sportsbook promos
Toronto Maple Leafs vs. Ottawa Senators preview
The Maple Leafs, seeking to close out their first-round playoff series, look to overcome their haunting 1-12 record in elimination games since 2017 as they host the desperate Senators on Tuesday night at Scotiabank Arena.
After building a commanding 3-0 series lead with back-to-back overtime victories, Toronto stumbled at the finish line Saturday when Jake Sanderson's overtime winner breathed new life into Ottawa's playoff hopes.
Stolarz has been a revelation for the Leafs, allowing just two goals in each of the first three games before Saturday's uncharacteristic four-goal hiccup.
The provincial rivalry has taken on new intensity with three consecutive overtime thrillers, though Toronto has historically dominated Ottawa in playoff matchups, winning all four previous series between the clubs.
Tim Stutzle and the Senators finally found success by creating more traffic around the net in Game 4, a strategy they'll likely continue as they face elimination for the second straight contest.
The Leafs' balanced attack, led by John Tavares and William Nylander, gives them home-ice advantage in what could be a tightly-contested Game 5 with both teams having adjusted to each other's playoff rhythms.
Toronto Maple Leafs vs. Ottawa Senators form
Toronto Maple Leafs vs. Ottawa Senators head to head
Toronto Maple Leafs
50%
Ottawa Senators
50%
Apr 26, 2025
Ottawa Senators
4 : 3
Toronto Maple Leafs
Apr 24, 2025
Ottawa Senators
2 : 3
Toronto Maple Leafs
Apr 22, 2025
Toronto Maple Leafs
3 : 2
Ottawa Senators
Apr 20, 2025
Toronto Maple Leafs
6 : 2
Ottawa Senators
Mar 15, 2025
Toronto Maple Leafs
2 : 4
Ottawa Senators
Jan 26, 2025
Ottawa Senators
2 : 1
Toronto Maple Leafs
Betting on the NHL?
Sporting Post is your trusted guide for NHL betting. We offer expert NHL predictions, top NHL picks, and the latest NHL odds. Our analysis and real-time insights help you make smart, confident bets. Make sure to use the best sportsbooks, sports betting apps, and betting sites. We've reviewed and tested the best NHL betting sites here.
