The Toronto Blue Jays (73-52) bring their playoff hopes to PNC Park on Tuesday night, facing a Pittsburgh Pirates (52-73) club that has proven capable of playing spoiler despite their disappointing season.
With Max Scherzer taking the mound for Toronto against Mitch Keller, this matchup features a veteran ace looking to help the Blue Jays maintain their push for October baseball against a Pirates starter who has been solid at home.
The betting market heavily favours Toronto at -275, but Pittsburgh's recent ability to compete with quality opponents makes this an intriguing spot for value seekers.
Pittsburgh Pirates vs. Toronto Blue Jays prediction: who will win?
For tonight's Pittsburgh Pirates vs Toronto Blue Jays matchup, our predictive model gives the Blue Jays a 72% chance of defeating the Pirates.
Pittsburgh Pirates: 28% win probability
- Worst offense in National League with just 444 runs scored in 126 games
- Poor .421 winning percentage places them 13th in NL standings
- Struggling recent form showing just two wins in last five games (WLLWL)
Toronto Blue Jays: 72% win probability
- Elite offensive production with 617 runs scored, ranking 2nd in the American League
- Strong winning percentage at .579, sitting 2nd in AL standings with 73 wins
- Solid recent momentum with three wins in their last five games (LLWWW)
At Sporting Post, our custom prediction model blends insights from leading MLB analysts to give you a clear edge.
Instead of sorting through endless opinions, we streamline expert picks, advanced team metrics, and market trends into one place. Our AI tracks top sources and assigns a confidence score to each prediction. These are averaged into a win probability that reflects the expert consensus. It gives you a data-backed view of what the sharpest minds in MLB expect.
Pittsburgh Pirates vs. Toronto Blue Jays preview
The Blue Jays arrive at PNC Park riding a solid 73-52 record but carrying some concerning pitching stats, ranking just 23rd in ERA at 4.25 despite their strong offensive output of 4.9 runs per game.
Max Scherzer takes the mound for Toronto with his pristine 3.17 career ERA and Hall of Fame credentials, facing a Pirates lineup that has managed just 88 home runs all season.
Pittsburgh's Mitch Keller has been inconsistent with a 4.52 ERA and will need to contain a Blue Jays offense that has already cranked 148 homers this year.
The Pirates' defensive efficiency ranks 10th in baseball at 70.7%, which could be crucial given their struggles to generate offense at just 3.51 runs per game.
Toronto's bullpen issues stand out with a disappointing 64.8% save rate, something Pittsburgh could exploit if they can keep this game close late.
With the Blue Jays heavily favored at -275, this shapes up as a test of whether Pittsburgh's solid pitching staff can neutralize Toronto's superior offensive firepower at home.
Betting on the MLB?
Sporting Post is your trusted hub for MLB betting coverage. We break down expert MLB predictions and deliver today’s MLB best bets with clear, data-driven analysis. Want secure and reliable options? Explore our top picks for MLB betting sites.